Pages

Tuesday, 14 May 2013

Shadowing The Carnegie Award



A Boy and a Bear in a Boat by Dave Shelton

I loved this. From what I have read this may not be a hot favourite to win the Carnegie award but nonetheless I loved it. When I am choosing a book to read one of the things that deters me is a review that tells me a book is “heart-warming” or that I will find it “uplifting”. This tends to make me feel manipulated by the publisher and the general hype surrounding a book. It is going to be difficult for me to describe this charming and slightly surreal story without using either of these descriptions.  



This is about a boy who gets into a boat with a bear and asks to be taken “to the other side”. We never learn why they are taking this journey nor where exactly they are travelling to and we don’t even discover their names. At first things go well for the duo; the sky is blue, the sea is calm and the mood is tranquil. After a couple of days it dawns on the boy that they may be lost. Will the bear admit that they are lost? Oh no, definitely not. He is most definitely a “glass half full” type of bear. From this point on there are a number of adventures or “unforeseeable anomalies” as the bear describes them. These range from a rather dodgy looking last sandwich to a large and terrible sea-monster and events of varying difficulty in between.

It is the journey that is important rather than the destination as we eavesdrop on the conversation between the boy and the bear as they continue on their way. Dave Shelton’s writing is so engaging and if there can be such a thing he appears to be a master of comic timing on the written page. There were several points where I chuckled out loud, especially during the “on-board entertainment”. The relationship between the two is appealing and the bear particularly is a loveable character being kind, caring and comforting although at times a little clueless. At first the boy is frankly a bit irritating but as the story progresses his character develops as he matures and accepts some responsibility. I grew to care and it can’t only be me who is willing the pair on to find land and happiness.

The best children’s books are those that can be enjoyed on many levels and this one does that extremely well. It would be possible to view this as an allegory of life itself and the need to keep going no matter what and to learn to rub along with others in sometimes trying circumstances. Perhaps a useful starting point for a philosophical discussion in school?  However it would also be great read aloud for younger children and could be read by competent readers of about 9 plus.

The illustrations throughout by the author are a huge part of the story and convey the emotions of the characters beautifully. They are simply gorgeous and add much to the story. I enjoyed this book very much and would recommend it highly to children and adults. It is both heart-warming and uplifting. Please don’t let that put you off. 


Wednesday, 1 May 2013

Shadowing The Carnegie Award

Wonder by R J Palacio

Wonder is an extraordinary book. It tells the story of a ten year old boy called Auggie who is about to start at middle school and his experiences during his first year there. Auggie was born with severe genetic facial disfigurement and has been home-schooled by his parents up to now. Starting a new school is difficult for many children but for Auggie the situation is made much harder as others appear to be unable to treat him as the ordinary boy he so desperately wants to be because of the way he looks.

The story is initially told by Auggie himself, an endearing and likeable boy with a sense of humour and obsessed with Star Wars; I warmed to him quickly. As the book progresses the story is told by several of the other characters including Auggie's elder sister, Via and his friend Jack. This works very well as the story continues to move forward and each of these characters is altered in some way by their relationship with Auggie. I particularly liked the section by Via as it conveyed extremely well the complexity of her feelings and the inevitable problems encountered by siblings of children who require so much of their parents' attention. The chapter "written" by her felt very real to me. Despite the difficulties she faces coping with typical teenage traumas, to a certain extent on her own, her love for her younger brother is obvious. Although there are no sections written by Auggie's parents the author manages to make them come to life through others' descriptions of them. The telling of the story in different voices also adds an extra dimension to some of the incidents that occur explaining why a character may have acted in a particular manner. However there are still some characters who come out of this story badly, in particular a mother at Auggie's school.

This is a relatively easy read with short chapters, some less than a page long, suitable for children of about ten plus. However this is a special book with an important message. Although there are quite a few books about children overcoming adversity this one stands out. It demonstrates the importance of celebrating difference and is full of warmth, sadness, bravery and humour, but more than anything it is about the power of kindness. I think every child should have a teacher like the wonderful and wise Mr. Tushman, the headmaster of Auggie's school. As a school librarian I will be recommending this to pupils, teachers and parents. A must read.